5 Ways You Misunderstand Quantum PhysicsHe starts off saying that a particle is not really a particle.The words we use to describe quantum ideas are abysmal. Here are the worst offenders.
Particle, Wave, Measurement and Observer, Spin, Orbital
Later he say it hard to interpret spin as spin if the particle were really a particle.
Put together, he makes no sense. There is no problem interpreting spin as spin, once you accept that a particle is not really a point particle.
He complains about how other physicists explain quantum mechanics, but he is just as bad.
For a physicist to say that quantum spin is not spin is like saying quantum energy is not energy, or quantum momentum is not momentum. Quantum spin is absolutely quantized version of classical spin. The argument is that a point particle cannot have intrinsic angular momentum. That is like saying an electron cannot have a charge, because a point particle with a charge would have to have infinite charge density.
A typical electron in an atom occupies an orbital, to use another term this guy dislikes. It is not localized at a point.
No comments:
Post a Comment