Voigt transformations in retrospect: missed opportunities?It ends with this strange conclusion:One more essay on the Einstein-Poincaré priority dispute
Olga Chashchina1, Natalya Dudisheva2, Zurab K. Silagadze 2,3 ...
We demonstrate this Whiggish approach on the example of Woldemar Voigt’s 1887 paper. ...
With a little imagination, one can connect Voigt’s paper to the notorious Einstein-Poincaré priority dispute, which we believe is a Whiggish late time artifact.
In light of this immense and still continuing progress of modern physics, attempts to retrospectively induce an artificial Poincaré-Einstein priority dispute and rewrite the history seem minute. We will be happy if this arid and futile dispute will come to its end. There is nothing scientific in it and its presence only emphasizes hideous traits of human nature. However, there is no single thing we can do, except writing this article, to help to end this unfortunate dispute. It remains, like aging Einstein, to repeat after Ecclesiastes ’Vanity of vanities, all is vanity’.The paper has a lot of discussion of Voigt, and of variations of the Lorentz group. It also discusses Lorentz-Poincare-Einstein priority in detail. It mostly agrees with Whittaker:
Forty-three years later, in 1953, Whittaker published a revised edition of his book, which now included a second volume covering the years from 1900 to 1926 [128]. The chapter devoted to relativity was called “The relativity theory of Poincaré and Lorentz” and its content left little doubt that Whittaker attributes the whole credit for the discovery of special relativity almost exclusively to Poincaré and Lorentz. About Einstein’s groundbreaking 1905 paper it was said that “Einstein published a paper which set forth the relativity theory of Poincare and Lorentz with some amplifications, and which attracted much attention”.But then it argues that we should credit Einstein anyway:
However, Whittaker’s conclusion, implicitly shared by many modern physicists who had taken a trouble to indeed read Poincaré’s papers, is wrong. This conclusion is based on the retrospective reading of Poincaré’s papers. However, in retrospective reading of really deep papers, and there is no doubt that Poincaré’s relativity papers are really very deep, the reader can see much more than it was possible to see by contemporaries, including the author, who were bound by concrete historical context and prejudices of those days. If we inspect the physical literature of the founding period of relativity (1905-1918), we will clearly see that the scientific community never hesitated to give Einstein a due credit, and there was no such a thing as Poincaré’s version of relativity “accessible and perceived as such by physicists of the times” [35]. It is a historical fact that the relativistic revolution, as seen in the contemporary physical literature of those days, rightly or wrongly is dominated by only one name, the Einstein’s papers playing the major role, while Poincaré’s ones being left virtually unnoticed [35]. The importance of these papers was recognized only later.Even if this were historically accurate, it is very strange to credit Einstein over Poincare just because some physicists of the day were too stupid to understand what Poincare had published.
But it is not true that Einstein's version of relativity dominated, or that Einstein was the only name noticed. Nearly everyone in 1905-10 who wrote about Einstein's relativity called it "Lorentz-Einstein theory". Nobody credited Einstein with being dominant.
Furthermore, Lorentz-Einstein theory was soon superseded by Minkowski's relativity, and that became much more popular than Lorentz-Einstein. A flood of new papers started to appear in 1908, and they were mostly based on Minkowski.
Minkowski published two big relativity papers, a detailed one in 1907, and a more popular one in 1908. They he died, so he was not part of any priority dispute. His 1907 paper cited Poincare, but not his 1908 paper.
While Poincare's papers were under-appreciated, they were noticed, and known to everyone in the field at the time. Maybe Einstein did not understand them, but Minkowski did, and Poincare's relativity quickly dominated. Those main ideas were clock synchronization, Lorentz symmetry group, indefinite metric, 4D spacetime, covariant electromagnetism. Many thought that these ideas were original to Minkowski, but they were first published by Poincare.
I wrote a whole book on this subject, and this article confirms what I wrote. Those who have studied the matter seriously cannot deny that relativity is due to Lorentz and Poincare. But they concoct crazy reasons for crediting Einstein anyway.
In this case, the argument is that Poincare's papers were very deep, but unnoticed and had not any influence at the time. But that is plainly not true, as Minkowski cited them, and so did Pauli's 1921 relativity textbook. And furthermore, it was Poincare's non-euclidean geometry approach that quickly became dominant.
The paper says:
Einstein’s silence is more difficult to explain. It is reasonable to assume that young Einstein, like most other physicists of those times, just lacked the proper mathematical education to dully appreciate Poincaré’s work. “More surprisingly, Einstein continued to ignore Poincaré’s contribution in all his later writings on special relativity and in his autobiographical notes” [136]. For late Einstein it is impossible to assume that he was not capable to recognize the importance of Poincaré’s work. How can we then explain Einstein’s silence? We think he simply had not read Poincaré’s key papers on relativity until perhaps later times.This is crazy. Einstein was a world-famous scholar, and he was famous for relativity more than anything. Is it possible that he did not read the leading paper on relativity, written by Europe's leading scholar?
I guess it is possible that Einstein did not understand it, and gave up on it. But if that is true, then we should stop talking about Einstein in connection with relativity. He was just a poor student of the subject, and not a player. He did not grasp Poincare's ideas until Minkowski explained them.
Here is how Lorentz dismissed Einstein's contribution:
From the scientific point of view, the fundamental difference between the conceptual foundations of the Lorentz-Poincaré æther based theory from one side, and Einstein’s special relativity from another, played the crucial role. Most succinctly this difference was expressed by Lorentz himself: ‘the chief difference being that Einstein simply postulates what we have deduced, with some difficulty, and not altogether satisfactorily, from the fundamental equations of the electromagnetic field” [133].This is because Lorentz had proved the constant speed of light from Maxwell's equations, and proved that Maxwell's equations could hold in other inertial frames, and proved that his theory could explain the Michelson-Morley experiment.
The one physicist who supposedly credited Einstein over Poincare was Planck:
Now about relativity of simultaneity. Relativity of simultaneity was considered by Einstein himself and his contemporaries as the most crucial and revolutionary aspect of special relativity. For example Max Planck in his lectures given at Columbia University in 1909 (consequently published by him in 1910) so describes Einstein’s ideas on space and time:This shows that Planck did not understand Poincare. The new conception of time was from Poincare, not Einstein, and the use of non-euclidean geometry was crucial to understanding what Poincare and Minkowski did. Planck obviously did not realize that, as he dismissed non-euclidean geometry.“It need scarcely be emphasized that this new conception of the idea of time makes the most serious demands upon the capacity of abstraction and the power of imagination of the physicist. It surpasses in boldness everything previously suggested in speculative natural phenomena and even in the philosophical theories of knowledge: non-euclidean geometry is child’s play in comparison.And, moreover, the principle of relativity, unlike non-euclidean geometry, which only comes seriously into consideration in pure mathematics, undoubtedly possesses a real physical significance. The revolution introduced by this principle into the physical conceptions of the world is only to be compared in extent and depth with that brought about by the introduction of the Copernican System of the universe” [15].
As was already mentioned above, relativity of simultaneity was originally Poincaré’s invention.
The paper cites Damour to say:
“Poincaré never believed in the physical relevance of the conceptual revolution brought by Einstein in the concept of time (and extended by Minkowski to a revolutionary view of the physical meaning of space-time)” [140].Nobody ever believed in Einstein's conceptual revolution in the concept of time, because there was no such thing. We get relativistic time from Lorentz, Poincare, and Minkowski. That Damour paper says:
Let us note that Max Planck was the first scientist who understood the revolutionary nature of the new einsteinian conceptual setup. In 1910 he wrote that “This principle [of Relativity] has brought about a revolution in our physical picture of the world, which, in extent and depth, can only be compared to that produced by the introduction of the Copernican world system.” He also wrote that “In boldness it [Special Relativity] probably surpasses anything so far achieved in speculative natural science, and indeed in philosophical cognition theory; non-Euclidean geometry is child’s play in comparison.”[10].There was no "new einsteinian conceptual setup." Planck is referring to special relativity, not anything original to Einstein.
It might seem like a new insight for Planck to compare relativity to Copernicus in 1910, but Poincare already famously made that comparison in 1905. Planck was five years late.
I am still a little puzzled by the above paper saying:
Poincaré-Einstein priority dispute ... There is nothing scientific in it and its presence only emphasizes hideous traits of human nature.Why does it say this? One can certainly compare the scientific content of the relevant papers, and examine their correctness, originality, and similarity to modern ideas. This paper discusses a dozen scientific issues related to the dispute, so why would it say there is nothing scientific?
And what are those "hideous traits of human nature"? Einstein is the only one who gets accused of doing anything dishonest or unethical, while almost everyone gives him a free pass. So those hideous traits can only refer to Einstein, or those who give him a free pass.
Here is my interpretation. Einstein is idolized for various reasons. He was a Jew, a Communist, a determinist, a anti-positivist, an anti-Nazi, a believer in unified field theory, a quantum skeptic, a plagiarist, an impostor, a liar, etc. Criticizing him is considered a heresy. So expert opinion has to be to concede that others had relativity before Einstein, but to refuse to criticize anyway. How else to explain a paper like this?
Yes, Einstein showed hideous traits of human nature. That is the inescapable conclusion to studying the history of relativity.
Here is a recent video on Voigt. It correctly explains that Einstein contributed nothing to special relativity, and that it had all been done better before him. The channel just dropped another video on Einstein. I do not agree with everything he says, but he is mostly correct about Einstein not deserving the credit for relativity.
No comments:
Post a Comment