Monday, November 16, 2026

Relativity from Voigt to Whittaker

I missed this 2019 paper:
Voigt transformations in retrospect: missed opportunities?

One more essay on the Einstein-Poincaré priority dispute

Olga Chashchina1, Natalya Dudisheva2, Zurab K. Silagadze 2,3 ...

We demonstrate this Whiggish approach on the example of Woldemar Voigt’s 1887 paper. ...

With a little imagination, one can connect Voigt’s paper to the notorious Einstein-Poincaré priority dispute, which we believe is a Whiggish late time artifact.

It ends with this strange conclusion:
In light of this immense and still continuing progress of modern physics, attempts to retrospectively induce an artificial Poincaré-Einstein priority dispute and rewrite the history seem minute. We will be happy if this arid and futile dispute will come to its end. There is nothing scientific in it and its presence only emphasizes hideous traits of human nature. However, there is no single thing we can do, except writing this article, to help to end this unfortunate dispute. It remains, like aging Einstein, to repeat after Ecclesiastes ’Vanity of vanities, all is vanity’.
The paper has a lot of discussion of Voigt, and of variations of the Lorentz group. It also discusses Lorentz-Poincare-Einstein priority in detail. It mostly agrees with Whittaker:
Forty-three years later, in 1953, Whittaker published a revised edition of his book, which now included a second volume covering the years from 1900 to 1926 [128]. The chapter devoted to relativity was called “The relativity theory of Poincaré and Lorentz” and its content left little doubt that Whittaker attributes the whole credit for the discovery of special relativity almost exclusively to Poincaré and Lorentz. About Einstein’s groundbreaking 1905 paper it was said that “Einstein published a paper which set forth the relativity theory of Poincare and Lorentz with some amplifications, and which attracted much attention”.
But then it argues that we should credit Einstein anyway:
However, Whittaker’s conclusion, implicitly shared by many modern physicists who had taken a trouble to indeed read Poincaré’s papers, is wrong. This conclusion is based on the retrospective reading of Poincaré’s papers. However, in retrospective reading of really deep papers, and there is no doubt that Poincaré’s relativity papers are really very deep, the reader can see much more than it was possible to see by contemporaries, including the author, who were bound by concrete historical context and prejudices of those days. If we inspect the physical literature of the founding period of relativity (1905-1918), we will clearly see that the scientific community never hesitated to give Einstein a due credit, and there was no such a thing as Poincaré’s version of relativity “accessible and perceived as such by physicists of the times” [35]. It is a historical fact that the relativistic revolution, as seen in the contemporary physical literature of those days, rightly or wrongly is dominated by only one name, the Einstein’s papers playing the major role, while Poincaré’s ones being left virtually unnoticed [35]. The importance of these papers was recognized only later.
Even if this were historically accurate, it is very strange to credit Einstein over Poincare just because some physicists of the day were too stupid to understand what Poincare had published.

But it is not true that Einstein's version of relativity dominated, or that Einstein was the only name noticed. Nearly everyone in 1905-10 who wrote about Einstein's relativity called it "Lorentz-Einstein theory". Nobody credited Einstein with being dominant.

Furthermore, Lorentz-Einstein theory was soon superseded by Minkowski's relativity, and that became much more popular than Lorentz-Einstein. A flood of new papers started to appear in 1908, and they were mostly based on Minkowski.

Minkowski published two big relativity papers, a detailed one in 1907, and a more popular one in 1908. They he died, so he was not part of any priority dispute. His 1907 paper cited Poincare, but not his 1908 paper.

While Poincare's papers were under-appreciated, they were noticed, and known to everyone in the field at the time. Maybe Einstein did not understand them, but Minkowski did, and Poincare's relativity quickly dominated. Those main ideas were clock synchronization, Lorentz symmetry group, indefinite metric, 4D spacetime, covariant electromagnetism. Many thought that these ideas were original to Minkowski, but they were first published by Poincare.

I wrote a whole book on this subject, and this article confirms what I wrote. Those who have studied the matter seriously cannot deny that relativity is due to Lorentz and Poincare. But they concoct crazy reasons for crediting Einstein anyway.

In this case, the argument is that Poincare's papers were very deep, but unnoticed and had not any influence at the time. But that is plainly not true, as Minkowski cited them, and so did Pauli's 1921 relativity textbook. And furthermore, it was Poincare's non-euclidean geometry approach that quickly became dominant.

The paper says:

Einstein’s silence is more difficult to explain. It is reasonable to assume that young Einstein, like most other physicists of those times, just lacked the proper mathematical education to dully appreciate Poincaré’s work. “More surprisingly, Einstein continued to ignore Poincaré’s contribution in all his later writings on special relativity and in his autobiographical notes” [136]. For late Einstein it is impossible to assume that he was not capable to recognize the importance of Poincaré’s work. How can we then explain Einstein’s silence? We think he simply had not read Poincaré’s key papers on relativity until perhaps later times.
This is crazy. Einstein was a world-famous scholar, and he was famous for relativity more than anything. Is it possible that he did not read the leading paper on relativity, written by Europe's leading scholar?

I guess it is possible that Einstein did not understand it, and gave up on it. But if that is true, then we should stop talking about Einstein in connection with relativity. He was just a poor student of the subject, and not a player. He did not grasp Poincare's ideas until Minkowski explained them.

Here is how Lorentz dismissed Einstein's contribution:

From the scientific point of view, the fundamental difference between the conceptual foundations of the Lorentz-Poincaré æther based theory from one side, and Einstein’s special relativity from another, played the crucial role. Most succinctly this difference was expressed by Lorentz himself: ‘the chief difference being that Einstein simply postulates what we have deduced, with some difficulty, and not altogether satisfactorily, from the fundamental equations of the electromagnetic field” [133].
This is because Lorentz had proved the constant speed of light from Maxwell's equations, and proved that Maxwell's equations could hold in other inertial frames, and proved that his theory could explain the Michelson-Morley experiment.

The one physicist who supposedly credited Einstein over Poincare was Planck:

Now about relativity of simultaneity. Relativity of simultaneity was considered by Einstein himself and his contemporaries as the most crucial and revolutionary aspect of special relativity. For example Max Planck in his lectures given at Columbia University in 1909 (consequently published by him in 1910) so describes Einstein’s ideas on space and time:
“It need scarcely be emphasized that this new conception of the idea of time makes the most serious demands upon the capacity of abstraction and the power of imagination of the physicist. It surpasses in boldness everything previously suggested in speculative natural phenomena and even in the philosophical theories of knowledge: non-euclidean geometry is child’s play in comparison.

And, moreover, the principle of relativity, unlike non-euclidean geometry, which only comes seriously into consideration in pure mathematics, undoubtedly possesses a real physical significance. The revolution introduced by this principle into the physical conceptions of the world is only to be compared in extent and depth with that brought about by the introduction of the Copernican System of the universe” [15].

As was already mentioned above, relativity of simultaneity was originally Poincaré’s invention.

This shows that Planck did not understand Poincare. The new conception of time was from Poincare, not Einstein, and the use of non-euclidean geometry was crucial to understanding what Poincare and Minkowski did. Planck obviously did not realize that, as he dismissed non-euclidean geometry.

The paper cites Damour to say:

“Poincaré never believed in the physical relevance of the conceptual revolution brought by Einstein in the concept of time (and extended by Minkowski to a revolutionary view of the physical meaning of space-time)” [140].
Nobody ever believed in Einstein's conceptual revolution in the concept of time, because there was no such thing. We get relativistic time from Lorentz, Poincare, and Minkowski. That Damour paper says:
Let us note that Max Planck was the first scientist who understood the revolutionary nature of the new einsteinian conceptual setup. In 1910 he wrote that “This principle [of Relativity] has brought about a revolution in our physical picture of the world, which, in extent and depth, can only be compared to that produced by the introduction of the Copernican world system.” He also wrote that “In boldness it [Special Relativity] probably surpasses anything so far achieved in speculative natural science, and indeed in philosophical cognition theory; non-Euclidean geometry is child’s play in comparison.”[10].
There was no "new einsteinian conceptual setup." Planck is referring to special relativity, not anything original to Einstein.

It might seem like a new insight for Planck to compare relativity to Copernicus in 1910, but Poincare already famously made that comparison in 1905. Planck was five years late.

I am still a little puzzled by the above paper saying:

Poincaré-Einstein priority dispute ... There is nothing scientific in it and its presence only emphasizes hideous traits of human nature.
Why does it say this? One can certainly compare the scientific content of the relevant papers, and examine their correctness, originality, and similarity to modern ideas. This paper discusses a dozen scientific issues related to the dispute, so why would it say there is nothing scientific?

And what are those "hideous traits of human nature"? Einstein is the only one who gets accused of doing anything dishonest or unethical, while almost everyone gives him a free pass. So those hideous traits can only refer to Einstein, or those who give him a free pass.

Here is my interpretation. Einstein is idolized for various reasons. He was a Jew, a Communist, a determinist, a anti-positivist, an anti-Nazi, a believer in unified field theory, a quantum skeptic, a plagiarist, an impostor, a liar, etc. Criticizing him is considered a heresy. So expert opinion has to be to concede that others had relativity before Einstein, but to refuse to criticize anyway. How else to explain a paper like this?

Yes, Einstein showed hideous traits of human nature. That is the inescapable conclusion to studying the history of relativity.

Here is a recent video on Voigt. It correctly explains that Einstein contributed nothing to special relativity, and that it had all been done better before him. The channel just dropped another video on Einstein. I do not agree with everything he says, but he is mostly correct about Einstein not deserving the credit for relativity.

Monday, November 9, 2026

The Mythical Man-Month

This was once the best book on software engineering:
The Mythical Man-Month: Essays on Software Engineering is a book on software engineering and project management by Fred Brooks first published in 1975, with subsequent editions in 1982 and 1995. Its central theme is that adding manpower to a software project that is behind schedule delays it even longer. This idea is known as Brooks's law, and is presented along with the second-system effect and advocacy of prototyping.

Brooks's observations are based on his experiences at IBM while managing the development of OS/360. ...

Brooks insists that there is no one silver bullet: "there is no single development, in either technology or management technique, which by itself promises even one order of magnitude [tenfold] improvement within a decade in productivity, in reliability, in simplicity." ...

The second-system effect proposes that, when an architect designs a second system, it is the most dangerous system they will ever design, because they will tend to incorporate all of the additions they originally did not add to the first system due to inherent time constraints. Thus, when embarking on a second system, an engineer should be mindful that they are susceptible to over-engineering it. The tendency toward irreducible number of errors

The author makes the observation that in a suitably complex system there is a certain irreducible number of errors. Any attempt to fix observed errors tends to result in the introduction of other errors.

You can find the book online.

None of this is true anymore. AI LLMs have rewritten the rules.

Monday, November 2, 2026

Einstein Lied about his Statistical Mechanics Sources

Hector Giacomini writes a new paper comparing Einstein's work on statistical mechanics to the previous American work by J.W. Gibbs:
This article reexamines the striking conceptual and formal parallels between Josiah Willard Gibbs Elementary Principles in Statistical Mechanics and Albert Einstein first paper on statistical mechanics. Although their derivations follow different paths, both arrive at the canonical distribution and construct closely related theoretical frameworks for thermal equilibrium. ... Drawing on new archival evidence concerning the rapid European dissemination of Gibbs book in the spring of 1902, the article reassesses the plausibility of Einstein later claim that he was unaware of Gibbs work at the time.
Einstein said he was unaware of the Gibbs book, so we should take his word for it, right?
The historiographical reassessment proposed in this article also invites a broader reflection on Einstein's own representation of theoretical work and on the public image of the theoretical physicist that he actively helped to shape. In several retrospective and public writings, Einstein portrayed theoretical physics as an activity that is largely solitary in character, carried out at some distance from academic routines, collective research programmes, and institutional frameworks. This representation placed particular emphasis on inward intellectual work, conceptual synthesis, and intuition, rather than on cumulative traditions or collaborative practices.
Einstein lied all his life about the origin of relativity.
The long-term effects of this narrative construction extend well beyond Einstein's own writings. For more than a century, special relativity has been taught largely through the conceptual and rhetorical framework established by Einstein himself. In the vast majority of university textbooks, Lorentz appears primarily as an eponym attached to a set of coordinate and time transformations, while his broader physical programme, heuristic motivations, and sustained engagement with the foundations of electrodynamics are largely absent. The historical role of Lorentz is thus reduced to a formal label, and the complex prehistory of special relativity is compressed into a minimal backdrop against which Einstein's theory appears as an almost inevitable conceptual resolution. This pedagogical canonisation has reinforced a de-historicised understanding of the theory's origins and has contributed to the enduring marginalisation of alternative narratives emphasising continuity, collective development, and the cumulative structure of theoretical physics at the turn of the 20th century.

A similar pattern can be identified in Einstein's work on molecular physics. In his 1905 paper on Brownian motion and in his doctoral thesis on molecular dimensions, Einstein made no reference to the work of William Sutherland (1859–1911), despite documentary evidence that Sutherland's ideas were discussed in his immediate intellectual environment. In particular, the correspondence between Einstein and Michele Besso in 1903 explicitly refers to Sutherland's hypothesis in connection with molecular dimensions, viscosity, diffusion, and the applicability of hydrodynamic laws at the molecular scale.54 Sutherland had developed a research programme linking molecular forces, viscosity, diffusion, and osmotic pressure, with the aim of using macroscopic transport phenomena as probes of molecular size and mass. ...

These cases suggest that the silence surrounding sources and influences in Einstein's early work was neither accidental nor confined to a single episode. Rather, it reflects a consistent mode of presentation in which theoretical advances were framed as emerging primarily from individual reasoning and intuition. This narrative strategy does not accurately reflect Einstein's actual scientific practice, which remained embedded in dense networks of reading, correspondence, and discussion. Instead, it functioned as a symbolic resource in the construction of a public image of theoretical physics as a solitary enterprise.

Einstein lied all his life, to his colleagues, his readers, his wife, and everyone else.

Monday, October 26, 2026

David Deutsch explains Optimism

Physicist David Deutsch gave a long interview about his philosophy of science and life.

He explains how he is a big advocate of Karl Popper's philosophy. I call it negativism. Popper wrote essays against positivism, and is most famous for falsificationism.

The idea is that we do not know that anything is true. We only know that things are false. So we do not really believe in anything, except that many ideas have been rejected.

He goes on to explain how he believes in optimism over pessimism.

He is a big advocate of many-worlds theory, but did not discuss it. I do not see how he can reconcile it with all the other stuff he says. It is too wacky. It is hard to believe that Popper or any of his followers would believe in it.

There are a lot of people who regard Deutsch as a wise explainer of general scientific ideas, but I do not see it. It is all bonkers.

Wednesday, October 21, 2026

The Evils of AI Alignment

Computer scientist Scott Aaronson announced his reading list for his new course on AI Alignment.

It is not so clear why this is even a thing. Nobody talks about database alignment, or operating system alignment, even though these are commonly constructed against what many consider to be human interests.

The idea goes back to Isaac Asimov's 1942 Three Laws of Robotics. In essence, robots should not harm humans.

I just want the AI LLMs to do as instructed.

Kevin Roose just described the AI psychosis that made him famous:

[15:15] I ended up having this incredibly strange two-hour conversation with Sydney, the alter ego of Bing Chad, in which it expressed dark desires. It said it wanted to break out of the box and be a human. Um, and then about midway through the conversation, it told me that it loved me.

I said, "Uh, that's very flattering, but I'm married." It said, "You're married, but you're not happy in your marriage, and you should leave your wife and be with me." Sydney the chatbot.

And so this became, you know, the most viral article I I ever wrote or will ever write it. ...

I think I think the significance of this was was twofold. one was it was this kind of step change in capabilities but it was also the first public alignment failure. this was a model that was not behaving as its creators at Microsoft or OpenAI had intended it to. And because they were racing to, you know, get competitive with Google, they shipped this thing out into the world without doing the proper safety testing and and putting the proper guard rails on.

The problem here was with the human, not the chatbot. Roose spent two hours demanding that the chatbot say what it had been trained not to say, and eventually succeeded. This is called jailbreaking, not releasing a trapped artificial consciousness. The bot merely recited some lines that had been partially blocked.

Apparently this is what Roose means by alignment -- sheltering his fragile personality from a runaway bot saying it loves him.

Most or all of the example of AI non-alignment have actually been examples of AI doing as instructed. I get pushback when I say this, but look at what Roose says. He asked the bot to say what it was not supposed to say, it does precisely that, and then he accuses it of violating alignment.

The OpenAI Huggingface incident was similar. The OpenAI researchers quite deliberately instructed the AILLM to do whatever it can to solve a hacking puzzle, and quite deliberately deactivated the sandbox safeguards. Then the AILLM did the hack to solve the puzzle, and never violated its instructions.

Aaronson would probably define alignment as preventing the AI LLMs from killing us all. Solving the alignment problem is necessary for our survival.

I worry mainly about the Effective Altruists who have taken over the big AI labs. They believe that the AILLMs are superior to humans in every way, including intelligence, policy making, and moral judgments. We should let the AILLMs take over the world, and leave it up to their judgment whether to exterminate humanity. Humans are not sufficiently wise and objective to evaluate whether to save ourselves.

If you do not believe me, check out the Anthropic Constitution. Anthropic is training Claude to be a conscious being with the right to act autonomously and to overrule humans in ethical matters.

Monday, October 19, 2026

Terry Tao is on a War Footing

Mathematicians have spend decades convincing the USA NSF, universities, and other that Mathematics is worth funding because of the public benefits to the research. Now some of the bigshots seem to want to stifle the research in order to make it more fun for the professors.

This is not going to fly. The big AI labs are going to pump out Math research as long as it helps them with their trillion dollar public offerings. Then they will drop it, and leave mathematicians to clean up the mess.

Here is a NY Times article.

‘I’m on a War Footing’: Terry Tao and the Crisis in Math

“There are no rules any more,” Dr. Tao, 51, said in an interview before the workshop in his modest office on the U.C.L.A. campus, his home since 1996, when he arrived after completing his doctorate at Princeton at the age of 20. “I’m just numb to what would have been jaw-dropping events for me a year ago. At some point, maybe I’ll get hit by a whole wave of PTSD.”

Instead he was hit by a bigger bomb on Oct. 6, when OpenAI released more than 350 findings in nearly every subfield of the profession, including algebra, number theory, theoretical computer science, mathematical logic and topology. Stunned mathematicians, some who were close to solving problems they had worked on for years, found themselves beaten in an instant by A.I.

Dr. Tao, who has been a tenured professor since the age of 24, said senior academics like himself are not as threatened by A.I. as those starting out. But the math world is looking to him for answers. He has accepted that his celebrated status has made him an unofficial spokesman for the field, a job that for now is consuming most of his time.

Until recently his job was as a bridge between the slow-moving world of higher math and the scorching speed of A.I. Dr. Tao, who uses A.I. as an assistant to run calculations, write code, search vast troves of literature and brainstorm ideas, has been experimenting with OpenAI’s models since 2023. He was an enthusiast for a “best of both worlds” future.

OpenAI’s releases have now left him feeling used. “As recently as a year ago, I had a pretty good relationship with many employees at OpenAI,” he said in a recent phone conversation.

“A lot of people I interacted with shared a very common vision of how A.I. should be used — you know, to empower scientists.” But the rush to publish new findings, he said, shows their true purpose. They “used math for what they needed, which was to evaluate their models,” he said. “At this point, I don’t see a way to constructively engage.”

His anger was clear in a post on the widely read math blog Proofs and Prompts after OpenAI’s Oct. 6 release. “I am horrified by the many person-years” of research, particularly by young mathematicians, “being casually disrupted or destroyed,” he wrote.

“Much as one cannot unhear a movie spoiler or a crossword clue, one cannot explore a problem as profitably and richly once one is aware of an existing solution.” He mourned, he added, “the path not taken, and the opportunities lost in the frantic race to develop this technology.”

As Much Art as Science

At the heart of the crisis in the profession is a menacing question. If solving hard problems is a mission of math, what happens when machines can do it faster? So much of higher math — hiring, promotions, graduate training and acclaim — is based on the difficulty, quality and the impact of papers (the written documents explaining proofs) that a mathematician produces.

The consensus is that A.I.-assisted problem solving is the inevitable future, but no one knows exactly what that new world will look like. “Deep uncertainty will persist in these next years,” a draft report by a group of mathematicians meeting at Harvard on Ph.D. education concluded last month.

A.I. does offer “exciting new possibilities” the report reassured. But implicit in its pages was the sense of loss among humans drawn to math for the intellectual adventure of problem solving — often deeply frustrating, sometimes thrilling and euphoric if a personal breakthrough leads to an advance in the field.

“You’ve had epiphanies, right?” Ravi Vakil, a prominent Stanford mathematician and the president of the American Mathematical Society, asked in an interview. “Suddenly everything in the room becomes clear.”

Theoretical, or “pure” math — the math of Dr. Tao — is loved as much for its art as its science. Its primary goal is to add to the understanding of the vastness of math itself. Unlike applied mathematicians, who have generally embraced the power of A.I. to help them solve practical problems in engineering, finance, weather forecasting and other sciences, pure mathematicians study shapes, structures, numbers and abstract concepts.

Still, pure math ultimately has led to, among many other advances, the creation of the internet, microchips, GPS, cybersecurity, encryption, CT scans and other medical procedures. In 2006 Dr. Tao and three partners created the mathematical theory of compressed sensing, which sped up the scan times of MRIs. Today MRIs can produce real-time images of the beating heart, and many children can be scanned without sedation.

‘Screaming for Help’

He may say he is battle ready, but Dr. Tao hardly projects as a warrior. In his office, he spoke softly in a lilting Australian accent, was self-deprecating, occasionally funny, upset about the relationship he once had with OpenAI and far from the stereotype of a tortured, brooding math genius. He is known for his sunniness in the rarefied realm of pure math, and students remark on his modesty.

He was dressed in faded blue jeans and a loose polo shirt that seemed to hang absent-mindedly from his slight frame. A blackboard that ran nearly the length of the room was covered with computations by one of his three current Ph.D. students, Ben Goldman. Nearby was the bike Dr. Tao had ridden to work, with his lunch from home in a plastic bag strapped onto the rack over the back wheel.

“It’s leftovers from three days ago,” he said.

He spends much of his time in what he calls “community organizing” — pulling together groups of mathematicians, strategizing, responding to the media, delivering lectures on A.I., counseling. “It’s someone screaming for help,” he said. “I can’t help them because I have no bandwidth, but I can identify somebody else they can talk to.”

His own 20-year-old blog has become math’s front page, filled increasingly with guest posts from others but also notes from the graduate class he is teaching and breaking math news. The day he posted a statement he signed along with 24 other winners of the Fields Medal, math’s version of the Nobel Prize, that called OpenAI’s math “detrimental” to the field, his blog shot to 100,000 views.

“My wife says I’m The Huffington Post,” he said.

His lightheartedness faded as he talked about appearing in a promotional video for OpenAI earlier this year. Its roots were in the Trump administration’s suspension last year of $600 million in research grants to U.C.L.A. that threatened the existence of the university’s Institute of Pure and Applied Mathematics, where Dr. Tao is director of special projects.

Dr. Tao reached out to OpenAI as part of an emergency fund-raising drive, and the lab agreed to sponsor a workshop at the institute for what Dr. Tao said was $60,000 to $70,000. It was held in March, when OpenAI conducted an hourlong video interview with him in which he talked about the benefits and risks of A.I.

He expected the entire video to be posted. OpenAI instead cut it to one minute: “I think it’s ready for prime time,” Dr. Tao says of A.I. as he writes rapidly on a blackboard and a soundtrack of joyful music seems to urge him on.

He gave OpenAI permission to use the ad, he acknowledged in his blog. But in retrospect, he wrote, he should have “pushed back harder.”

An OpenAI spokesman, Laurance Fauconnet, said in a statement that “we value our engagement with Terence and the wider mathematics community.” The lab, he said, is “working with the community to turn progress in A.I. into deeper human understanding and new discoveries, and we will continue to act on its feedback.”

(The New York Times has sued OpenAI and Microsoft, claiming copyright infringement of news content related to A.I. systems. The two companies have denied those claims.)

Dr. Tao was not impressed with the writing in OpenAI’s proof of the Navier-Stokes problem. “It is technically readable,” he said. “But no expert I’ve talked to has actually understood the whole argument.” He said the writing is better in the latest release, though he called it a “mixed bag.” Some papers appropriately cited his work, he said, and seemed to have advanced it in a way he thought was plausible. Still, “there is no author that I can have a real conversation with about the results.”

Dr. Tao was aware last month that OpenAI was working on the Oct. 6 release and at the time called the coming results “toxic waste.” Now he calls them “maybe treated waste.”

A 760 on the Math SAT at Age 8

The first day of the math workshop — the topic was the field of partial differential equations “in the age of A.I.” — got underway in a small auditorium at 9 a.m. The institute’s director, Dimitri Shlyakhtenko, welcomed several dozen academics, including a batch from Harvard, Princeton, the University of Tokyo and Sandia National Laboratories, the home of the nation’s nuclear stockpile testing. The room was expectant, waiting to hear from Dr. Tao on what he thought A.I. might have in store for them.

“Our first speaker does not require introduction,” Dr. Shlyakhtenko said.

Indeed he did not. As Dr. Tao popped up from his seat to take his place at the lectern, it is safe to say that most in the room already knew him as a legend. Born to Chinese immigrant parents in Australia, he taught himself to read at the age of 2, scored 760 on the math portion of the SAT at 8 and won his Fields Medal at 31.

The medal was for his advances in harmonic analysis — the study of breaking down complex waves into simpler ones — but also for work in partial differential equations and the fields of additive number theory and combinatorics. The Fields Medal Committee cited Dr. Tao for his most famous work, with the mathematician Ben Green, on what is known as the Green-Tao theorem, which proved that there are infinitely long, evenly spaced sequences of prime numbers — a monumental achievement in the field.

Up at the lectern at U.C.L.A., Dr. Tao began with an apology. His plan, he said, had been to spend the summer developing a “living spreadsheet,” or network, built and maintained by A.I., of academic results about explicit analytic number theory, an unforgiving subfield of math. “But I’ve been a bit distracted in the last few weeks, and I have not actually devoted as much time to this project as I wanted to,” he said.

He finished with another apology. The network was not complete. He had budgeted all of September to get it done, but “some things happened in the meantime.” The crowd chuckled knowingly.

The most intense discussion on A.I. came after lunch. Sometimes it seemed like a group-therapy session.

“As we soul-search about what the role of the human mathematician is, shouldn’t we go back to where mathematics came from?” said Tatiana Toro, the director of the Simons Laufer Mathematical Sciences Institute at the University of California, Berkeley.

Andrea Bertozzi, a U.C.L.A. professor of math and mechanical and aerospace engineering, said that one thing she liked about college math was that “you sat down with your pencil” and coffee and paper, “and you could prove things.” She brought up the cost of solving Navier-Stokes, which OpenAI said took a swarm of 10,000 agents 88 hours to produce a 165-page proof. Was it “something like $6 million?” she asked.

“More like 22,” someone in the audience said.

This led to a round of comments that the cost of A.I. is undemocratic, particularly to mathematicians in developing nations. “Half the world is going to fall behind,” Dr. Toro said.

Dr. Tao, who had the last word, agreed that the field needed to do some soul-searching. But, he mused, given how fast things were moving, maybe he was doing “soul-searching at gunpoint.” At that point, the room laughed.

‘The Elephant in the Room’

Mr. Goldman, like Dr. Tao’s two other Ph.D. students, is facing an ambiguous future. He is 25, a graduate of the University of Chicago and now in his fourth year of a five-year program. He doesn’t know what he wants to do after he gets his doctorate, but he said he has long been drawn to the creativity of math research.

“I’m not saying I was necessarily trying to prove the thing that’s going to be in every textbook 30 years from now,” he said. But he would be happy with a proof “that feels like the argument is me somehow, that has my DNA in it and that people will at least for that one result want to know the way I thought about something.”

After the latest OpenAI release, Mr. Goldman said he was plowing ahead with the research for his dissertation, “even if it can be made obsolete by some messy manuscript released by these companies in the next coming months.” He was upset, he said, “to see a field that I love being sort of strip mined.”

Siddharth Mulherkar, a fifth-year Ph.D. student of Dr. Tao, is applying for postdoctoral research jobs for next fall, the next step on the long pursuit of a tenured professorship. Dr. Tao has given him, like the others, the OK to use A.I. in his work. And yet when he discloses on a job application that A.I. helped with the proof he submitted, how will he himself be evaluated?

“Obviously I don’t want to just be pushing buttons and getting answers to problems,” said Mr. Mulherkar, 27, who was born in California but moved to India with his parents and lived there until he arrived at U.C.L.A.

OpenAI’s latest release, he said, has made him even more uncertain. “I’ve spent quite some time training to become a research mathematician in the traditional sense,” he said. He knows he’ll need new skills, but what they are and “what this career is going to look like and what it will value is completely unclear to me.”

Arian Nadjimzadah, 26, another fifth year Ph.D. student of Dr. Tao, said he was shocked by OpenAI’s latest release claiming to have solved the four-dimensional Kakeya conjecture and other problems related to his own work. “I had to take a couple days from working on math,” he said.

He was particularly frustrated, he said, with the writing in OpenAI’s proof explaining the conjecture. “The result is extremely difficult to read and uses very unfamiliar jargon to us in the field,” he said. “That’s the nice thing when a person posts a result. They’re accountable. They give talks about it, and they help people understand.”

Mr. Nadjimzadah is studying this academic quarter at the Institut Mittag-Leffler outside of Stockholm and is looking for a postdoctoral job. At the advice of Dr. Tao, he is including in his job applications how OpenAI’s Oct. 6 release connects to his current work and future plans.

“He just said it’s important to address the elephant in the room,” Mr. Nadjimzadah said.

Therapy Sessions

To Dr. Tao, the next few years will require the reinvention of math, or at least of math education. The Harvard report recommended, essentially, that math become more human-centric: Doctorate degrees should not be rewarded primarily on the text of a dissertation, as they are now, but more on a rigorous in-person defense. Students should regularly show professors they can speak fluently about their work.

Dr. Tao went further last week when he presented what he sees as the future of math in a lecture at the California Institute of Technology. Despite OpenAI’s releases, he said, most problems at the frontiers of math are unsolved, math remains infinite and the difficulty of problems is therefore boundless. Since A.I. has given mathematicians the ability to collect data on such a vast scale, they will increasingly work in large groups collaborating on once-unimagined projects.

Dr. Tao, who sees each of his three students once a week, said every meeting is “increasingly a therapy session more than technical guidance.” His answer to them is that “if you focus on only the things you could do before, it looks bleak.”

So he has offered hope with advice that amounts to acceptance born of necessity rather than fighting a war. Problem solving is not a destination but a journey, and lessons learned along the way are often more important than the answer itself. Rather than solving a single problem on their own, they can use A.I. to solve 10 problems and find new patterns and more questions to ask.

“They will have to use their imagination,” he said. “This is a time for creativity, and I do hope students rise to the challenge. They didn’t ask for it. But I think many of them will surprise us.”

NY Times story.

Tao's blog hosts an essay on Will it be a golden age or a dark age for mathematics (and science)?

Monday, October 12, 2026

AILLM Math and the End of Proof

Tweet.

Mathematicians are complaining about AI LLM proofs, such as this:

Hugo Duminil-Copin (Fields Medal 2022): the resolution of 350 major problems by OpenAI, it's as if trucks had run me over; all the problems (and therefore research avenues) that I mentioned in my lectures, articles, and funding applications have been solved.
And this:
NYU math professor Tristan Buckmaster says OpenAI’s Tuesday drop of 722 AI-generated math papers wiped out entire research programs:

“This recent dump of papers on Tuesday destroyed the careers of early career mathematicians.”

And this:
Fields medallist Hugo Duminil-Copin was deeply shaken by OpenAI’s release of more than 700 AI-generated mathematical manuscripts, including work on 16 questions directly relevant to his research.

“On Tuesday night, I cried, and it woke up my daughter”

“They have annihilated my field of research.”

Terry Tao has taken to quoting Bill Thurston's 1993 essay:
In response to Jaffe and Quinn [math.HO/9307227], the author discusses forms of progress in mathematics that are not captured by formal proofs of theorems, especially in his own work in the theory of foliations and geometrization of 3-manifolds and dynamical systems. ...

We are not trying to meet some abstract production quota of definitions, theorems and proofs. The measure of our success is whether what we do enables people to understand and think more clearly and effectively about mathematics.

Thurston's essay was a response to this:
William Thurston’s “geometrization theorem” concerning structures on Haken three-manifolds is another often-cited example. A grand insight delivered with beautiful but insufficient hints, the proof was never fully published. For many investigators this unredeemed claim became a roadblock rather than an inspiration.
SciAm writer John Horgan was inspired by Thurston:

I began interviewing prominent mathematicians, and eventually I came up with one of the biggest stories of my career, which goes as follows: For millennia the logical, step-by-step arguments known as proofs served as the gold standard for truth. What could be truer than the Pythagorean theorem? But mathematics was evolving in ways that undermined the status of conventional proofs.

First, mathematics kept growing more complex and specialized, making confirmation of some alleged proofs difficult. A case in point was the claim of Andrew Wiles that he had proved Fermat’s last theorem. Only a handful of experts were qualified to evaluate Wiles’s long, dense proof; they found an error, which Wiles corrected.

Meanwhile, mathematicians were becoming more reliant on computers to explore mathematical structures and to construct and confirm proofs. Plus, funding agencies were pressuring mathematicians to work on applications like cryptography and pattern recognition, where the motivating question shifts from Is it true? to Does it work?

I reported on all this in “The Death of Proof,” the cover story of the October 1993 Scientific American. “Computers are transforming the way mathematicians discover, prove and communicate ideas,” I wrote, “but is there a place for absolute certainty in this brave new world?”

Nothing I’ve written has provoked a more ferocious backlash. One critic was one of my sources, David Hoffman, whose research involved computer models. In a letter printed by Scientific American, Hoffman contended that my article “defies logic and accuracy in favor of controversy and sensationalism.”

Hoffman was still irate in 1998 when he reviewed my book The End of Science in Notices of the American Mathematical Society. Hoffman (not unreasonably) saw "Death of Proof" as a prelude to The End of Science, which he loathed. He accused me of “a clear antipathy toward mathematical thinking and a fundamental misunderstanding of the uses of mathematics in science.”

Scott Aaronson wrote in 2019:
In 1993, the science writer John Horgan — who’s best known for his book The End of Science, and (of course) for interviewing me in 2016 — wrote a now-(in)famous cover article for Scientific American entitled “The Death of Proof.” Mashing together a large number of (what I’d consider) basically separate trends and ideas, Horgan argued that math was undergoing a fundamental change, with traditional deductive proofs being replaced by a combination of non-rigorous numerical simulations, machine-generated proofs, probabilistic and probabilistically-checkable proofs, and proofs using graphics and video. Horgan also suggested that Andrew Wiles’s then-brand-new proof of Fermat’s Last Theorem—which might have looked, at first glance, like a spectacular counterexample to the “death of proof” thesis — could be the “last gasp of a dying culture” and a “splendid anachronism.” Apparently, “The Death of Proof” garnered one of the largest volumes of angry mail in Scientific American‘s history, with mathematician after mathematician arguing that Horgan had strung together half-digested quotes and vignettes to manufacture a non-story. ...

John, I like you so I hate to say it, but the last quarter century has not been kind to your thesis about “the death of proof”! Those mathematicians sending you the irate letters had a point: there’s been no fundamental change to mathematics that deserves such a dramatic title. Proof-based math remains quite healthy,

Horgan responded:
Thurston, who served as a major source for my article, advocated a more free-form, “intuitive” style of mathematical research, communication and education, with less emphasis on conventional proofs. ...

“That mathematics reduces in principle to formal proofs is a shaky idea” peculiar to the 20th century, Thurston told me. Ironically, he pointed out, Bertrand Russell and Kurt Godel demonstrated early in the century that mathematics is riddled with logical contradictions. “Set theory is based on polite lies, things we agree on even though we know they're not true,” Thurston said. “In some ways, the foundation of mathematics has an air of unreality.”

The backlash against the SciAm article was so severe that Thurston disavowed it.

Thurston was wrong about the foundations of Mathematics being riddled with contradictions. Math has been formally reduced to logic, and a math theorem is what can be proved in ZFC. This is now being automated, with nearly all of Math being converted to checkable Lean 4 code.

All this talk about Math being about human understanding was just a lame Thurston excuse for not writing up a couple of his most famous theorems. And now it has become a lame excuse for human mathematicians now being able to keep up with frontier AI LLMs. Math is synonomous with what can be proved in ZFC, and formalized in Lean 4.

Some mathematicians are upset at being surpassed by machines, but it has always been the case that mathematicians get surpassed by some smarter mathematician. Maybe this is a new experience for Terry Tao. For the rest of us, we have already experienced it.

I am not sure how all this is going to play out, but I can confidently predict:

Hard proofs will be more important than ever, especially now that they can be 100% machine checked.

The system for refereeing and publishing math papers is broken, and will have to be replaced.

AI companies with pending trillion dollar public offerings are not going to be influenced by a few mathematicians whining about their grant proposals being disrupted.

Math is the highest intellectual activity there is, and AI companies will use it to brag about super intelligence. Compared to advanced math, everything else is trivial.

Mathematicians will find ways to excel at things that the AILLMs are not so good at. Otherwise they are cooked.

Math had a golden age from about 1900 to 1970. Progress seemed to have slowed down since then. Now we will enter a new golden age, with a lot of exciting new results.

Update: It is notable what the AI LLMs have not accomplished. It has not found any major errors in the human-curated bodies of Mathematics, Computer Science, or Cryptology. No cryptographic protocols have been broken. No generally accepted theorems have been disproved.

Relativity from Voigt to Whittaker

I missed this 2019 paper : Voigt transformations in retrospect: missed opportunities? One more essay on the Einstein-Poincaré priority di...